ENESJoin the club
Argentina · River Plate · Lionel Messi · Claudio TapiaUnconfirmed report

Report: Messi's goodbye started a war, and Argentina could leave River's Monumental

By the Data Desk · ·

First reported by La Nación (Ariel Senosiain) · 9 OCT 13:57

Four days after Lionel Messi said goodbye to Argentina in front of a full Monumental, the stadium sang against the man who runs Argentine football. La Nación reports that the AFA has already decided the national team will not play at River Plate's ground again, a decision neither the federation nor the club has confirmed.

  • La Nación's Ariel Senosiain wrote on 9 October: “En la AFA existe una decisión tomada: la selección argentina no jugará más en el estadio Monumental.” Clarín repeated it on Saturday night.
  • The row started with the farewell show on 6 October: the AFA's producer, Marketing Sports, blamed River for the failures; River's answer, through club sources, blamed the producer.
  • The Monumental holds 85,018, the largest stadium in South America. The alternative named, La Plata's Estadio Único, holds about 53,000 and is still being renovated.
Why it mattersArgentina have played their biggest home nights at the Monumental. If the federation walks away over a party that went wrong, the first era without Messi starts with a smaller home and an open fight between the AFA and its most powerful club.

The farewell itself went to plan on the pitch: Argentina beat Benin 3-0 on Tuesday 6 October and Messi had a hand in all three goals. The show around it did not. The sound failed, the drone display was mocked, and a power cut ended the closing act by Grupo Cali. Two days later Marketing Sports, the company the AFA hired, posted a statement saying River removed the giant screen three days after the AFA announced the event, refused an alternative LED screen on the pitch and ran the stadium's sound and lighting (La Nación).

Behind the scenes, River answered off the record, and in detail. According to club sources quoted by La Nación and Infobae, the screen's removal was announced on 8 July, River had played seven home games without it, sound and lighting were the producer's job, and River had expressly suggested a generator that the producer chose not to pay for. La Nación adds that Tapia had asked River, through vice-president Ignacio Villarroel, to give up the stadium rent for the night.

Then came Saturday. Before River beat Estudiantes de Río Cuarto 1-0, all four stands sang “Chiqui Tapia botón”, and this time River's barra joined in (Clarín). Earlier that afternoon, at Barracas Central, the club Tapia used to run, the home fans had chanted against River's president Stefano Di Carlo during a 2-0 win over Huracán (La Nación). Tapia has not answered publicly.

What is known and what is not: La Nación says no date is attached to the decision because Argentina have no home games planned in the short or medium term; the November window is expected to be friendlies abroad. La Plata's renovated Estadio Único is the alternative La Nación names. The AFA and River have made no official statement.

Our take · Editorial view

A power fight, not a drone failure

If La Nación is right, our editorial team reads this as a power fight between Tapia and River, and the farewell as the excuse. Swapping a stadium of 85,018 for one of about 53,000 that is still being rebuilt costs Argentina tickets and atmosphere, not River, which fills the Monumental every other weekend. We think the decision will hold only as long as Argentina have no big home game to sell; when one comes, watch whether the AFA still says no to its largest stadium.

18+Play responsibly

Updates

  1. Still open, with no official word from the AFA or River on the Monumental, but the first test has come sooner than we expected. On 16 October the AFA announced two home friendlies, Uruguay in Buenos Aires on 13 November and Costa Rica in Córdoba on 17 November, without naming the stadiums (La Nación); we had written that the November window was expected to be played abroad, and that was wrong. La Nación wrote on 17 October: "El duelo ante los uruguayos será en Buenos Aires, seguramente en la Bombonera"; if that holds, our view that the decision would bend once a big home game came along was wrong too.
Unconfirmed reportAt the time of writing, this information has not been confirmed. The analysis above is the view of our editorial team.